Choose sustainable index funds (with a greenwashing eye)
Low-cost index funds are still the sensible way to invest — and greener versions let you keep that simplicity while steering money away from fossil fuels and towards better companies.
Index investing won the argument for good reasons: it’s cheap, it spreads your risk across thousands of companies, and it quietly beats most people who try to be clever. The catch is that a standard world index owns a slice of everything — including the oil majors, miners and coal firms. Buy the whole market and you buy the problem along with it.
Sustainable index funds try to keep the good parts and screen out the worst. The honest truth is that “sustainable” covers a huge range, from a token tidy-up that still holds fossil fuels to genuinely fossil-free, tightly screened funds. The work is in reading past the label: the exclusion list and the EU’s Article 8 or 9 classification tell you far more than a leaf logo or the word “ESG” on the cover.
The nuance worth holding onto is that no index fund is morally spotless, and screening slightly narrows your diversification and can nudge fees up a touch. That’s a reasonable trade for many people, not a free lunch. Aim for broad, cheap and clearly screened, then automate a modest monthly contribution and let compounding do the heavy lifting. You don’t need the perfect fund — you need a sensible, greener one you’ll actually stick with for decades, which is where the real impact and the real returns both come from.
How to do it
- Start from a broad, low-cost world index as your benchmark, then look for its sustainable sibling — many providers offer an SRI or 'Paris-aligned' version of the same index.
- Check what the fund actually excludes: read the methodology for fossil fuels, weapons, tobacco and coal, not just the green-sounding name.
- Be wary of 'ESG' labels alone — under EU rules look for Article 8 (promotes sustainability) or the stricter Article 9 (sustainability is the goal) classification.
- Compare the ongoing charge (TER); a good sustainable index ETF should cost roughly 0.2–0.4% a year, not double a plain tracker.
- Check it's still properly diversified — an SRI screen trims the index, so make sure you're holding hundreds of companies, not a narrow niche.
- Set up a monthly automatic contribution (a Sparplan) so you invest steadily and ignore the noise.
Pro tips & pitfalls
- 'Best-in-class' ESG funds often still hold oil majors that score well against their peers. If you specifically want fossil fuels out, look for explicit exclusion or 'fossil-fuel-free' in the methodology, not just a high ESG rating.
- Don't chase a perfect fund. A broad, cheap, fossil-screened index you actually keep buying every month beats an ideologically pure one you fret over and abandon.
What it's good for
Good for the planet
- Cuts CO₂ A fossil-screened world index strips out coal, oil and gas producers, so your monthly contributions stop flowing to the highest-emitting companies in the market.
Good for you
- Grows skills Learning to read a fund's exclusion methodology and EU Article 8/9 label is a skill you'll reuse for your pension, ISA and every future investment.
Good for people
- Fairer & ethical SRI and Paris-aligned indexes tilt towards firms with stronger labour, governance and environmental records, nudging capital towards companies behaving better.
Find your next hack
Browse more money hacks, or jump to another part of your life.
More money hacks All categories